Jersey Shore Anglers Say New Permit Lottery Is Pushing Locals Off Their Own Beaches
Many New Jerseyans have enjoyed surf fishing at Island Beach State Park for decades. This is a family tradition, mental escape, and coastal connection. That relationship is straining when a new state lottery system left thousands of lifelong fisherman without beach vehicle permits.
New Jersey’s 2026 random lottery for mobile sport fishing permits replaces first-come, first-served, generating criticism. These permits let four-wheel-drive cars park straight on the sand for surf fishing, which requires heavy gear and frequent shoreline movement. State officials claim the approach ensured justice as demand increased, but local fishers believe it did the opposite.
Permit holders for decades were suddenly denied admission. Some had access for 30–50 years. They rejected for more than administrative reasons. It felt private. Many say they lost a place where they learned to fish with parents, raised kids, and celebrated life milestones. Many consider Island Beach State Park a second home, not a luxury.
The new approach awarded 8,000 permits via online lottery, with applicants outnumbering spaces. New Jersey residents won most permits, but hundreds were given to out-of-state applicants, increasing local scorn for a tax-funded public park. Out-of-state fishermen report license plate-based verbal abuse and beach confrontations on social media.
State environmental officials said the lottery was introduced to reduce overcrowding, protect delicate dunes and animals, and reduce traffic interruption from long waits. Applications surged rapidly during the COVID-19 pandemic, when outdoor recreation and Island Beach gained national attention online. Authorities said a random draw was the best way to meet demand without congestion or safety risks.
Local fishers say justice should reflect history and community. They say permit holders partied on beaches instead of fishing, hurting experienced fisherman who followed park laws. People who lost access are frustrated by alcohol, inadequate parking, and little policing.
Surf fishing bait and tackle shops say the policy change has caused one of the most contentious events in decades. Shop owners say customers feel mislead and question if Island Beach’s tranquil, conservation-minded fishing culture can survive the upheaval.
Lawmakers face pressure to act. Fishermen already shut out of the 2026 season would miss any permit changes or early purchasing opportunity for New Jersey residents. The state is reviewing replies and considering extending the lottery beyond next year.
Some fishermen are removing their remaining legitimate permit badges from truck windshields before the season ends, unsure if they will have another chance. Probabilities and paperwork are not their issue. Identity, legacy, and the sadness of losing a treasured New Jersey institution, one permit at a time.
Sources
NJ DEP, NJ State Parks, Forests, and Historic Sites Division, NJ Beach Buggy Association, and local fisherman and bait and tackle store owners submit statements.
